Joining the fight against prostate cancer with Prostate Cancer UK

Dataro recently joined forces with the team at Prostate Cancer UK to test how AI predictive modelling would perform against traditional list selection methods in an Autumn Appeal. The results showed that Dataro’s selections increased revenue by over £11,000 and attracted more than 440 new gifts that otherwise would have been missed, laying a solid foundation for future appeals.

Key results

  • Over 440 extra gifts that would have been missed
  • Over £11,000 additional raised
  • Significant increase in response rate

How we did it

Prostate Cancer United Kingdom is innovating in the way it uses data to select which supporters to contact with which campaigns. Traditionally, charities have used simple models or manual methods such as RFM (Recency, Frequency, Monetary value) analysis to create segments that group supporters together based on recent giving history.

Dataro’s software uses machine learning to analyse patterns of donor behaviour across all fundraising campaigns and understand each donor’s unique giving journey. Each donor is then given a ‘propensity score’ reflecting their probability of giving in an upcoming appeal. This process was conducted using Dataro’s integration with Blackbaud Raiser’s Edge CRM.

In this experiment, we compared the results from both approaches using the same methodology as with organisations such as Parkinson’s UK and Greenpeace:

  1. We generated propensity scores for every donor reflecting their propensity to give to the direct mail appeal. Using these scores, we generated a recommended campaign list.
  2. Prostate Cancer UK compared the Dataro list against its own proposed campaign list to identify three categories of donor:
    1. Donors appearing in both lists were labelled blue;
    2. Donors Prostate Cancer UK selected but which Dataro would removed were labelled red; and
    3. Donors Dataro selected but which Prostate Cancer UK had not chosen were labelled green.
  3. The appeal was sent to all donors from both lists, allowing us to compare responses from the Dataro selections vs the Prostate Cancer UK selections.

Analysing the Results

The results were clear. Dataro’s machine learning list performed better than the classic list across all metrics. Critically, the results showed:

  • Organisations not using machine learning are missing out on a significant number of donations in their appeals
  • Organisations typically include far too many donors, resulting in wasted mail and increased cost

Net Revenue

A key test of performance is net revenue. In this case, net revenue takes into account the costs of the campaign and the total amount raised. We could see that the net return from the blue segment was the highest, but that the extra donors selected by Dataro significantly outperformed the extra donors selected using the classic model. This resulted in an overall 3.6% increase in net returns.

Response Rate

Response rates are useful to track the effectiveness of list selections. In this analysis, we can see how the extra donors selected by Dataro responded far better than the extra donors selected with RFM, with a response rate of over 8% compared to less than 3%. The donors appearing in both lists also performed strongly, with a response rate over 10%.

ROI

A final key indicator for the campaign is the ROI, which in this case takes into account the total mail cost and the return from the Dataro list vs the classic segmentation. The results showed an ROI of over 10 from the Dataro campaign compared to 8.7 from the normal selection, an increase of 14.8%.

These results again show that better campaign selections driven by machine learning predictive modelling result in more gifts and increased returns in direct mail appeals, paving the way towards higher performing appeals in the future.

What they said

“One man dies every 45 minutes from prostate cancer; it’s now the most commonly diagnosed cancer in the UK, and the Coronavirus pandemic has made living with a diagnosis only harder. Working with Dataro has been great, and it’s work like this that will help Prostate Cancer UK reach its ultimate goal to saves men’s lives.””

Holly Matthews

Direct Marketing Manager

More Case Studies

How RFDS Vic’s data-driven approach has lifted their fundraising to new heights

How RFDS Vic’s data-driven approach has lifted their fundraising to new heights

Dataro have been working with Royal Flying Doctors Service Victoria since 2020 to help them implement data-driven fundraising strategies that deliver more donations and better fundraising ROIs across appeals, recurring giving and major gifts. As a not-for-profit aeromedical organisation, RFDS Vic rely on the generosity of their single,

Read more
QUT uses data to deliver better engagement strategies that help fund world-leading research

QUT uses data to deliver better engagement strategies that help fund world-leading research

In 2021 the Queensland University of Technology (QUT) advancement team were looking for a way to improve the efficiency of their engagement reporting and get better insights about their donors and fundraising program performance. While the existing reporting system worked well enough, the advancement team needed an easier

Read more
Helping RFDS Vic to engage the right major donors that help keep Flying Doctors flying

Helping RFDS Vic to engage the right major donors that help keep Flying Doctors flying

As a not-for-profit aeromedical organisation, Royal Flying Doctors Service Victoria rely on the help and generosity of the community to deliver essential health and emergency medical services.  While every donor has played an important role in keeping the Flying Doctor flying during a challenging few years, the growth

Read more
Chris O’Brien Lifehouse lifts appeal returns to help people living with cancer

Chris O’Brien Lifehouse lifts appeal returns to help people living with cancer

Chris O’Brien Lifehouse is a world-class integrated cancer treatment centre and hospital. A critical part of funding their work is the organisation’s appeals program. In 2020 the charity was looking for a way to increase net revenue by improving their campaign targeting. As part of their first campaign

Read more