2027 NONPROFIT FUNDRAISING BENCHMARK

2027 BENCHMARK

Dataro logo

The Abundance Dividend: How Top-Performing Nonprofits Grow 2.5x Faster

Revenue is up, efficiency is down, and 68 nonprofits can show us all how to grow 2.5ร— faster.

We analyzed a dataset of $62 billion in nonprofit fundraising data from 296 organizations large and small around the world. Explore the data here. Read the full analysis below.

19% higher revenue

compared to 2015

0% change

in median revenue per donor since 2015

Only 20% of first-time donors give again

within a year, down from 29% in 2015

66% of bequests

are a surprise

ABOUT THE REPORT

Authors

Nic Miller

Salvatore Salpietro

Nicole Ng

Prepared by

Fenwick

Share

There are many nonprofit fundraising reports, and most lump large organizations with small and assume environmental nonprofits operate exactly like healthcare systems. In this report, we expose those differences.

We offer one global story, but also frequent breakouts by region, cause type, and organization size, so you can see not just what works for some fictional average, but for a typical organization like yours.

This is possible because we work at a data analysis startup that has privacy-safe, fully anonymized access to a trove of nonprofit fundraising data stretching from the year 2000 to 2025. It accounts for 182 million donor records and $62 billion in giving. Weโ€™ve used that information to build a research tool, which we used to write this report. We hope it sparks a discussion on your team, and allows for greater objectivity.

One more thing. In this report, youโ€™ll find no hand-wringing about the future; no admonitions to โ€œlearn AI,โ€ nothing to keep you up at night. Just encouragement. And numbers. Because we too have watched the pall fall over this industry, and want to share that data tells a different, more complex, and oftentimes encouraging story.

Key metrics

296 nonprofits and foundations

$62 billion in fundraising revenue

908 million individual gifts

73.8 million distinct donors

3.3 million campaigns which targeted 1.6 billion contacts

820 million contacts and 19.8 million responses in the response-rate analysis.

Data ranges from 2000โ€“2025 (with many entries and exits)

26 countries in 3 regions

7 cause areas

Cause

Organizations

Healthcare

89

Social & public welfare

64

Faith & religion

39

Human rights

27

Environment

18

Hospice

17

Animal welfare

15

Four size bands

Size band

Annual fundraising revenue

This pool

Small

Under $1M

28 (9%)

Mid-sized

$1M to $10M

147 (50%)

Large

$10M to $100M

115 (39%)

Very large

$100M and above

6 (2%)

Three regions

This graphic represents where these organizations are domiciled, not where they have operations. Many are active around the world.

Trend charts follow the 256 organizations that report every year from 2015 to 2025: AU+NZ 78, UK+EU 118, US+Canada 44, and 16 in other countries.

Definitions

Donors

People who gave money in a given year, not names on a list.

Donor retention

A year-over-year figure that asks, of those who gave last year, how many gave again?

Second-gift rate

Asks, of an organization's brand-new, first-time, one-off donors, how many return to make a second gift?

Lifetime value per donor

An organisationโ€™s total revenue ever received divided by the total number of distinct donors it has ever had.

High performers

Organizations in the top quartile of revenue growth within their own cause, scored on five-year growth and the durability measure that defines their model (recurring share, retention, or lifetime value). In this way, we do not compare causes to one another.

Our research findings suggest that if you can predict where your revenue comes from, you can unlock what weโ€™re calling โ€œthe abundance dividendโ€โ€”a state of calm wherein everyone can finally focus on the mission.

We derived that from a certain cohort of nonprofits and foundations within this data set whose performance is markedly different: Those 68 organizations grow revenue 2.5ร— as fast, retain better, earn more per donation, and earn more frequent donations. When this becomes true for an organizationโ€”when funds are predictableโ€”it creates a sense of psychological abundance which leads to operational composure. These nonprofits can plan further ahead. Versus the converse, where money is always scarce, and small crises steer the organization.

We hope the recommendations in this report help you improve your own metrics, and move closer to abundance.

If you can predict revenue, you unlock the abundance dividend where everyone can finally focus on the mission.

Internal state of abundance

Stress less

Fewer emergencies

Plan further ahead

Hire better

Halo effect attracts donors

Success compounds

The typical (median) organization from the full 296 population keeps 58% of its donors, raises $509 from each, or $1,039 over the relationship, one $21 donation at a time. The typical organizationโ€™s average donation is $119, which shows the impact of large gifts.

Note that the above numbers do not add up nor lend themselves to math because they are medians, not averages.

2015

Today

0%

more gifts per donor per year since 2015, from 3.1 gifts to 4.6 (2.4)

%

2015

Today

0.0%

decline in median gift size, after inflation: from $21.1 ($28.16, in todayโ€™s dollars) to $21 (1.7)

%

The typical organization loses

0%

of its donors every year (1.9)

%

Outreach is up

0.0x

in the last 10 years

while response rates fell

0%

%

2000

Today

0.0x

One-off individual gifts have fallen from 19.2% of revenue in 2000 to 11.4% today (2.14, 2.15)

%

2015

Today

0%

more gifts per donor per year since 2015, from 3.1 gifts to 4.6 (2.4)

%

2015

Today

0.0%

decline in median gift size, after inflation: from $21.1 ($28.16, in todayโ€™s dollars) to $21 (1.7)

%

The typical organization loses

0%

of its donors every year (1.9)

%

Outreach is up

0.0x

in the last 10 years

while response rates fell

0%

%

2000

Today

0.0x

One-off individual gifts have fallen from 19.2% of revenue in 2000 to 11.4% today (2.14, 2.15)

%

2015

Today

0%

more gifts per donor per year since 2015, from 3.1 gifts to 4.6 (2.4)

%

2015

Today

0.0%

decline in median gift size, after inflation: from $21.1 ($28.16, in todayโ€™s dollars) to $21 (1.7)

%

The typical organization loses

0%

of its donors every year (1.9)

%

Outreach is up

0.0x

in the last 10 years

while response rates fell

0%

%

2000

Today

0.0x

One-off individual gifts have fallen from 19.2% of revenue in 2000 to 11.4% today (2.14, 2.15)

%

The most successful 68 organizations grow revenue 2.5ร— faster: 10% revenue growth per year, versus 4% (4.2)

These organizations retain 65% of donors versus 56% (4.2)

We identified 3 nonprofit models: (3.1)

  1. Recurring-driven. Used by environment and human rights.

  2. Loyal repeat one-off. Used by faith and religion, social and public welfare, animal welfare.

  3. Major gift. Used by hospice and healthcare.

The typical organization loses 42% of its donors every year

  • The median organization retains 58% of donors, and that number has been consistent since 2015 (1.9)

  • Cause matters more than region or size. The environmental cause retains donors at 76%; hospice keeps 43% (1.11)

  • High performers keep 65% of their donors against 56% for everyone else (4.2)

  • Recurring gift models help with retention, but are not the only method. Organizations with more than half their revenue recurring retain 76%, against 52% for those under 10% (5.9)

  • Thereโ€™s a second-gift cliff: Only 20% of first-time, one-off donors give again within a year, down from 29% in 2015 (2.10)

Prediction and automation are now essential

  • 66% of bequests were surprises and came from donors with less than $7,000 in lifetime value (5.8)

  • Outreach is up 4.7ร— in the last 10 years, while response rates fell 67% (2.5)

  • The number of campaigns that earn zero revenue has doubled (2.13)

  • Data analysis is hard: Even for this advanced group, untagged revenue ranges from 13% at environmental organizations to 67% at hospices (6.1)

Donations have shifted toward committed and planned money

  • One-off individual gifts have fallen from 19.2% of revenue in 2000 to 11.4% today (2.14, 2.15)

  • Three sources rose to replace them: regular monthly giving from 8.9% to 17.1%, corporate and trust income from 2.8% to 10.4%, and bequests from 4.9% to 9.6% (2.15, 5.3)

This report contains fundraising data, not expense data

We have no insight into money spent, so no way to calculate return on investment. We considered the following data within this report:

Revenue

Channels

Gift size

Donor lifetime value

Year-over-year change

Campaign success

Response rates

Segments (region, cause, size)

Conversion rates

Itโ€™s debatable whether this dataset is representative

Any nonprofit in this dataset works with a predictive modeling service (us), and thus these nonprofits are probably more advanced than is typical. This data set also suffers some survivorship bias: If a nonprofit performed so poorly it ceased operating, it would disappear from our list.

We report the median because a small number of large organizations pull the average up

All money is displayed in U.S. dollars at one fixed exchange rate, so cross-region dollar comparisons carry that exchange-rate assumption. Inflation adjustments deflate each organizationโ€™s revenue by its own countryโ€™s consumer price index, then we take the median, not a single blended deflator. Size bands are set by each organizationโ€™s own latest-year fundraising revenue. If a figure is based on fewer than three organizations, we do not publish it; or five, on the regional cause slide. Cells with fewer than 10 entries are marked as directional.

0.1 โ€” We report the median, because the average is deceptive
Each organization's annual revenue in U.S. dollars.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Axis capped at $100M with six organizations that are outliers.

Between 2015 and 2025, nonprofits grew their revenue and donor bases, and donors gave more frequently.

But when you consider inflation, that growth was much lower, and over that period, gift sizes declined by one quarter.

The typical organization grew revenue 19%

The overall story here is positive: Since 2015, organizations grew their annual revenue 65%, from $4.4 million to $7.2 million. Although, when you factor in inflation, that growth was more than two-thirds lowerโ€”just 19%. 

1.1 โ€” Median revenue growth per organization
Same fixed group each year, for the 256 organizations present every year, 2015-2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
The adjusted line deflates each organization's revenue by its own country's consumer price index before we take the median.

The organizations in our dataset collected donations in seven currencies. The inflation in each country also varied, so we deflated each organization by its own countryโ€™s consumer price index rather than a single blended rate.

The typical organizationโ€™s revenue rose 65%, from $4.4 million in 2015 to $7.2 million in 2025. In todayโ€™s money, it rose 19% because 2015โ€™s $4.4 million is worth $6 million now.

One caution on what that โ€œ19%โ€ means: It follows the middle organization in each year, and thatโ€™s a different organization from year to year. If you instead measure each organizationโ€™s own growth and take the middle one, the answer is 27%. The 19% describes where the middle of the sector sits; the 27% describes how a typical organization actually did.

This is all to say, these broad figures conceal a great deal of variation. One quarter grew 121% in real terms, 35% lost revenue after inflation, and one quarter lost 18% or more of their revenue.

1.2 โ€” Median revenue change from 2015-2025, with inflation
Each organization's inflation-adjusted revenue growth, 2015-2025, one bar per organization, ranked lowest to highest. There were 256 organizations present every year, and we calculated inflation by their country's currency, shown in 2025 money.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Each bar follows one organization from its own 2015 level to its own 2025 level. The 28 organizations above 300% are drawn at the 300% cap; the 10th-90th percentile spans -40% to +356%.
1.3 โ€” Inflation-adjusted revenue growth, by region
Median revenue per organization, 2015 to 2025, for the same fixed group each year within each region.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Two adjustments make the regions comparable: Each organization's revenue is deflated by its own country's consumer price index, so every year is stated in 2025 money, and all amounts convert to U.S. dollars at a single fixed rate, so the lines move when fundraising moves rather than when exchange rates do.

The typical organization grew its donor base 54%

The median donor base grew from 10,350 to 15,960 active donors. This is the number of people who actually gave, not just an increase in list size or marketable contacts.

Active donors increased from

0 โ†’ 10,350

%
1.4 โ€” Median donors per organization
Median active donors per organization, same fixed group.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
1.5 โ€” Median donors per organization, by region
Median active donors per organization, same fixed group each year within each region, 2015-2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Active means the donor gave at least once that year.

The typical organization raises $529 per donor, which is flat since 2015

The median revenue per donor grew from $394 to $529 from 2015 to 2025, which is flat when you consider inflation. Interestingly, this number appears consistent over that time within our population of 256 organizations that we can follow continuously from 2015 to 2025 and whose revenues range from <$1 million to >$100 million, which seems remarkable.

1.6 โ€” Median revenue per donor
Median revenue per donor, same fixed group, 2015-2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

The median gift size fell by 25.4%

The median gift in 2015 was $21.11, and a decade later, it is $21.00. With inflation, thatโ€™s actually a 25.4% decline. This is, no doubt, related to a general decline in purchasing power among the middle classes in the regions we studied. 

1.7 โ€” Median gift size over time
Median per organization, the same fixed group of 256 organizations each year.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
The 2025 figures are calculated by deflating each organization by its own country's consumer price index.

Gift size fell by about a third in both the U.S. and Canada and UK and European Union, and by a fifth in Australia and New Zealand.

1.8 โ€” Median gift size, by region
Median gift size per organization in 2025 money (USD), same fixed group each year within each region, 2015-2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Each organization's median gift is deflated by its own country's consumer price index before the median is taken.

The typical organization retains 58% of its donors year-over-year, which is unchanged since 2015

Like revenue per donor, retention is remarkably consistent year-over year. Here, we define retention on an organization-by-organization basis and ask, of last yearโ€™s donors, which ones gave again in the most recent year? That number always seems to be just under 60%.

Notably, we do not see any sustained pandemic dip.

1.9 โ€” Median donor retention
Median per organization, same fixed group each year, 2015-2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
1.10 โ€” Median donor retention, by region
Median donor retention rate per organization, same fixed group each year within each region, 2015-2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Retention is the share of an organization's donors from the prior year who gave again this year.
1.11 โ€” Median donor retention by cause area
Each bar shows the middle organization in that group, ranked by its own retention rate.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Causes with too few organizations to report are not shown.
1.12 โ€” Median donor retention by cause area, over time
Median year-over-year donor retention for the typical organization in each cause, 2015-2025. The dashed line is the pooled median of all 286 organizations.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Causes with too few organizations to report are not shown.
1.13 โ€” Median performance, by cause
The middle organization in each cause, 2025, USD.
Causeโ–ฒโ–ผOrganizationsโ–ฒโ–ผRevenue / donorโ–ฒโ–ผDonor retentionโ–ฒโ–ผRecurring shareโ–ฒโ–ผMedian giftโ–ฒโ–ผ
Healthcare86$57847.6%4.8%$17
Social & Public Welfare61$43162.5%13.9%$21
Faith & Religion39$36765.7%12.5%$27
Human Rights26$41662.7%32.6%$22
Hospice17$69043.2%3.5%$25
Environment16$29275.6%48.2%$15
Animal Welfare15$33364.8%20.4%$16
Causes with too few organizations to report are not shown.
1.14 โ€” Lifetime value per donor, by cause
The median organization's lifetime revenue per donor (USD).
Loading chartโ€ฆ

Pictured are donor bases by size category.

1.15 โ€” Donors per organization, by size
Median active donors per organization. The โ€œvery largeโ€ category is lighter because that sample size is small, just six organizations.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
1.16 โ€” Donor retention rate, by size
Median donor retention by size band.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
1.17 โ€” Revenue per donor, by size
Median USD raised per donor by size band.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
1.18 โ€” Donor retention, by cause and size
Gray cells feature three or fewer organizations, so we've grayed those out.
Healthcare
54%
44%
49%
n<3
Social & Public Welfare
31%
59%
67%
43%
Faith & Religion
67%
64%
66%
Human Rights
n<3
61%
66%
n<3
Environment
n<3
66%
76%
Hospice
43%
54%
Animal Welfare
67%
65%
n<3
Arts & Culture
n<3
Small
Mid-sized
Large
Very large
1.19 โ€” Donor and revenue growth after inflation, by region
Median growth 2015 to 2025. In the paired panels, light bars are as reported and solid bars are inflation-adjusted.
AU+NZ (n=78)UK+EU (n=118)US+Canada (n=44)Pooled (n=256)
Median revenue growth: as reported (light), inflation-adjusted (solid)
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Median donor base growth 2015โ†’2025
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Revenue per donor growth: as reported (light), inflation-adjusted (solid)
Loading chartโ€ฆ
The 256 organizations present in every year 2015โ€“2025: AU+NZ 78, UK+EU 118, US+Canada 44. Inflation-adjusted deflates each organization by its own country's consumer price index, in 2025 money.

All the list and revenue growth came despite falling gift sizes and campaign effectiveness. 

In this section, we explain why fundraising is up overall, yet has become more demanding of both organizations and donors.

The percent of recurring revenue rose 167%

The median percent of recurring revenue rose from 3% in 2015 to 8% in 2025, a 167% increase. Thatโ€™s good news. Though, as we discuss in chapter 5, a recurring subscription model isnโ€™t as helpful for increasing retention as you might think.

2.1 โ€” Percentage of recurring revenue
Recurring (regular monthly) giving as a share of revenue for the median organization, 2015-2025, same fixed group of 256 organizations every year.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Median per organization of recurring revenue plus total revenue from a balanced panel of 256 organizations present every year, 2015-2025.
2.2 โ€” Recurring revenue, by region
Recurring (regular monthly) giving as a share of revenue in 2025 for the median organization in each region.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Median per organization of recurring revenue plus total revenue. All organizations, including the 29 orgs in the โ€œother region,โ€ which are not shown separately.
2.3 โ€” Recurring revenue, by cause
Recurring (regular monthly) giving as a share of revenue in 2025 for the median organization in each cause, compared with all organizations.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Higher education and arts and culture are not shown. Data includes uncategorized organizations, not shown.

Gift sizes shrank 25.4%, which means nonprofits must do more just to stay the same

Gift sizes fell over the past decade, while revenue per donor and typical retention remained flat. This means organizations had to send more appeals and campaigns, and coax donors to give more often.

In response, giving volume grew: Donors now give 4.6 times per year, up from 3.1, a 48% increase. But one wonders, when does the fatigue set in? 

2.4 โ€” Giving frequency and value
Indexed to 2015, based on the median per organization, same fixed group.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

Outreach is up 4.7x, while response rates fell 67%

The number of contacts organizations targeted has grown and grown, only slowing in 2025. Meanwhile, response rates have dropped. There could be many reasons for this, and it demands additional research. 

One likely scenario: If outreach volume preceded falling response rates, as it seemed to, organizations were probably sending more messages to less qualified or known contacts. Likely, these fundraising teams had targets to hit, felt squeezed by declining gift sizes, and saw no other way. But if thatโ€™s true, this serves as a cautionary tale: Any short-term benefits of sending more appeals are outweighed in the long term as people stop responding. Over 10 years, donors have become 67% less responsive. 

The short-term benefits of sending more appeals are outweighed by the fact that over time, people just stop responding.

%
67%
decline in response rates since 2015
%
67%
decline in response rates since 2015
2.5 โ€” Contacts targeted and response rate
2015โ€“2025
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Indexed to 2015, all channels. The figures on this chart are sector totals: all warm contacts across 245 organizations divided by all responses. The median organizationโ€™s warm response rate fell from 4.5% to 2.8% between 2015 and 2025. In 2025, contacts targeted reached 4.7ร— their 2015 level while response rate fell to 0.33ร—. From 2015 to 2025, contacts targeted rose 369% and response rate fell 67%.
2.6 โ€” Response rate by size of organization
Median organizationโ€™s warm response rate by size band, same fixed group, 2015โ€“2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Share of contacts who gave to an existing-donor (warm) campaign, all channels. From 2015 to 2025, the mid-sized rate fell from 4.7% to 3.7%, while the large-organization rate fell from 4.4% to 2.3%.
2.7 โ€” Response rate by region
Median organizationโ€™s warm response rate by region, same fixed group each year within each region, 2015โ€“2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Share of contacts who gave to an existing donor (warm) campaign, all channels.
2.8 โ€” Response rate by cause
Median organizationโ€™s warm response rate by cause, same fixed group each year within each cause, 2015โ€“2025.
Causeโ–ฒโ–ผ2025 response rateโ–ฒโ–ผ2015 โ†’ 2025โ–ฒโ–ผOrganizationsโ–ฒโ–ผ
Faith & Religion
6.1%
7.3% โ†’ 6.1%19
Healthcare
3.2%
5.9% โ†’ 3.2%32
Hospice
3.2%
6.9% โ†’ 3.2%10
All organizations
2.8%
4.5% โ†’ 2.8%110
Animal Welfare (directional)
2.4%
3.7% โ†’ 2.4%8
Social & Public Welfare
2.2%
4.2% โ†’ 2.2%20
Environment (directional)
1.8%
1.5% โ†’ 1.8%7
Human Rights
1.7%
3.0% โ†’ 1.7%11
Share of contacts who gave to an existing-donor (warm) campaign, all channels. Hospice, Animal Welfare and Environment have fewer than 10 organizations and are directional. Higher Education is below the 3-organization bar and is not shown.
2.9 โ€” Response rate by channel
Median organizationโ€™s warm response rate by channel, 2015โ€“2025, for organizations targeting at least 10,000 warm contacts on that channel in the year.
Channelโ–ฒโ–ผ2025 response rateโ–ฒโ–ผ2015 โ†’ 2025โ–ฒโ–ผMiddle half, 2025โ–ฒโ–ผOrganizationsโ–ฒโ–ผ
Mail
3.4%
5.9% โ†’ 3.4%1.4% to 5.5%166
Phone
1.7%
3.4% โ†’ 1.7%0.3% to 3.0%43
Online (directional)
0.7%
2.7% โ†’ 0.7%0.0% to 2.4%30
Email
0.13%
0.14% โ†’ 0.13%0.02% to 0.77%80
Share of contacts who gave to an existing-donor (warm) campaign, by channel.

Second-gift rate has fallen from 29% in 2015 to 20% in 2023

At the same time that overall outreach seems less effective, donors are seeming less loyal. In 2015, nearly one-third of one-off gift donors (29%) gave again within 12 months. In 2023, it is one-fifth (20%). That steep decline means each newly acquired donor is worth relatively less to the organization.

2.10 โ€” Second-gift rate
The share of first-time, one-off donors who gave a second gift within 12 months.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Pooled across donors rather than averaged across organizations: Every donor counts equally, so organizations with the largest acquisition programs carry the most weight. Based on 24.2 million first-time, one-off donors from 2015 to 2023. Every cohort shown had a full 12 months to give again, so each year is measured the same way. The 2024 and 2025 cohorts are excluded because their 12-month windows have not closed.
2.11 โ€” Second-gift rate by region
This 12-month cohort is complete for every cohort shown. The 2024 and 2025 cohorts are excluded because including incomplete windows would depress the figures.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
2.12 โ€” Second-gift retention rate by cause
Share of first-time, one-off donors who gave a second gift within 12 months, by cause.
Causeโ–ฒโ–ผSecond gift within 12 monthsโ–ฒโ–ผ2015 โ†’ 2023 cohortโ–ฒโ–ผMedian monthsโ–ฒโ–ผ
Hospice
40%
57% โ†’ 34%3
Faith & Religion
39%
43% โ†’ 34%6
Animal Welfare
28%
30% โ†’ 25%5
All donors
23%
29% โ†’ 20%
Human Rights
23%
22% โ†’ 18%10
Environment
21%
32% โ†’ 14%6
Social & Public Welfare
21%
34% โ†’ 19%8
Healthcare
21%
22% โ†’ 18%10
Pooled across the 2015โ€“2023 cohorts. Every cohort shown has a complete 12-month window. The 2024 and 2025 cohorts are excluded because including incomplete windows would depress the figures.

The share of campaigns that raise zero funds has more than doubled, to 28%

We tracked unsuccessful campaigns as well, and the news here is not good. The number of campaigns that raised zero funds has more than doubled from 12% to 28% over the past decade. That organizations have seen as much growth as they have is impressive. It has been very hard-won.

2.13 โ€” Share of campaigns that failed to raise any funds
Median organizationโ€™s share of its campaigns with zero revenue, among all organizations reporting campaigns that year, 2015โ€“2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
A campaign is one appeal to one channel in one year. Organizations logging campaigns grew from 153 in 2015 to 243 in 2025.

So, how has revenue risen?

Nonprofits somewhat offset declining gift sizes and effectiveness through volume, but not entirely. Individual donors declined as a total share of income. Yet their median revenue rose because they diversified into accepting donations from a wider variety of sources, notably, corporations and trusts, which accounted for 2.8% of the total in 2000 and 10.4% in 2025. 

2.14 โ€” The shifting mix of gift types, average (not median)
Each gift categoryโ€™s share of total revenue, per year.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
2.15 โ€” The same mix, one baseline per category
Each gift categoryโ€™s share of total revenue, 2000 to 2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
2.16 โ€” Donation sources
Share of categorized revenue by gift type, all organizations, 2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Additional sources: (uncategorized) 3.0%; Stewardship 2.6%; Newsletter 0.9%; Membership 0.2%; Services, Administration and Gift Aid 0.1% each; Thank You, Receipt, Survey, Petition and Email to Target 0.0% each.

Not all the advice you hear out there applies to you. Hopefully that comes as a relief. 

We looked at the spectrum of performance within nonprofits and found that there isnโ€™t one measure of success, but three. Nonprofits growing revenue the fastest and most reliably tended to find that success in one of three operating models: 

High recurring

High retention

High lifetime value

You only need to be growing revenue and excel in one model area to find success. We find that the model type thatโ€™s best for you is closely tied to cause areaโ€”see pictured. Environmental and human rights tend to have a high share of recurring revenue. Animal welfare, social and public welfare, and faith and religion tend to have high donor retention. And hospice and healthcare tend to have higher than normal lifetime value. Excellence in this one area seems to offset whatever other deficiencies they face, such as low per-donor gifts or low retention. 

You only need to be growing revenue and excel in one area to find success.

3.1 โ€” The three fundraising models
Recurring share and donor retention are shown as percentages; lifetime value is shown in U.S. dollars.
Fundraising modelโ–ฒโ–ผRecurring shareโ–ฒโ–ผDonor retentionโ–ฒโ–ผLifetime valueโ–ฒโ–ผScored onโ–ฒโ–ผTypical causesโ–ฒโ–ผ
Recurring-driven41%68%$962Recurring shareEnvironment, Human Rights
Loyal repeat one-off13%64%$959Donor retentionFaith & Religion, Social & Public Welfare, Animal Welfare
Major gift4%47%$1,045Lifetime valueHospice, Healthcare
Each model is scored on its defining metric; associated causes are shown in the final column.

We tested this cause-model-growth relationship rigorously in three methods and found it durable and predictive. We define โ€œgrowthโ€ over a five-year window within the last seven years to show that the growth was repeated, and not lucky or due to one good year.  

What can nonprofit leaders conclude? That not all advice is relevant. You want advice from similar nonprofits with similar models. Maybe your hospice nonprofit doesnโ€™t need to figure out a subscription model after all, and can rather improve its existing appeals, as befits how people want to interact. (This is an idea, not a recommendation.) Often, it is better to focus on the preexisting natural patterns in your industry and do what youโ€™re already best at even better.

Of the 251 organizations we could score, 68 grew revenue two and a half times faster than the rest. 

These nonprofits grew revenue 10% per year against 4% for everyone else. Inflation widens that gap rather than closing it: Over the decade, the successful cohort nearly tripled its revenue in real terms while everyone else stayed flat. To measure this fairly, we searched for successful nonprofits within their cause area, where performance is actually comparable, not between causes. 

We settled on an equation. Within each cause, we rank every organization on its five-year revenue growth, and again on the metric that defines its model: recurring share, retention, or lifetime value. The two ranks average into one score, and the top quarter of that score within each cause are the high performers.

Key metrics

High recurring

Environmental, Human Rights

High retention

Faith and Religion, Social and Public Welfare, Animal Welfare

High lifetime value

Hospice, Healthcare

You can see all organizations by their blended score on a scatter plot, pictured. Not all successful organizations fell neatly within the upper-right quadrant, partly because we analyzed causes against one another and not against unlike causes. Itโ€™s also due to the fact that some organizations were so strong at one factor or the otherโ€”growth or modelโ€”that their overall score beat other more balanced organizations. 

4.1 โ€” High performers, measured on two axes
Each dot is one scored organization. We have highlighted the 68 high performers out of 251 scored, which represent the top quarter of the combined rank inside their own cause. This is why some top performers sit outside the upper-right quadrant.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Growth is the median five-year revenue CAGR across windows ending 2019โ€“2025.

That said, what is remarkable about this cohort of 68 is that they donโ€™t just do some things better than the rest: They do nearly all things better. For example, they keep 65% of their donors against 56%. They raise 19% of revenue from recurring gifts against 8%. And theyโ€™re worth $1,218 per donor over the relationship against $960. This is what weโ€™re talking about when we reference the so-called โ€œabundance dividendโ€: These organizations are doing better in all regards.

4.2 โ€” High performers in growth, retention, and more
Higher performers are those who are within the top quartile of performance within their own cause, or 68 of the 251 scored organizations.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Your modelโ–ฒโ–ผThe number that defines itโ–ฒโ–ผTypical (median)โ–ฒโ–ผHigh performers reachโ–ฒโ–ผ
Recurring-drivenRecurring share of revenue41%60%
Loyal repeat one-offDonor retention rate64%70%
Major gift / episodicLifetime value per donor$1,045$2,010

We back-tested this success cohort assumption thoroughly, and controlled for outlier factors by analyzing these organizations within their cause area. So for health and human services, the 2022 spike likely due to Russiaโ€™s war on Ukraine does not skew the results. Some factors we of course cannot control for, such as the impact of celebrities, the uneven distribution of world events, fads, or news cycles. If you have insights into how those might have affected the data, please write to us.

4.3 โ€” Emergency appeals as a share of revenue
Loading chartโ€ฆ

Moving up in the ratings can have a profound impact on a nonprofitโ€™s performance. Most are battling inflation and falling outreach effectiveness and dwindling gift sizes, while this successful group is growing. If we model how these two groups divergeโ€”the successful and everyone elseโ€”a 10-year chart shows a 2.5x difference in revenue growth. 

4.4 โ€” Inflation-adjusted revenue, by high performer
Median organization in each cohort, actual performance, 2025 money, back to 2015.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Each organization is deflated by its own countryโ€™s consumer price index. The median each year is over those with data that year, which ranges from 176 to 183 organizations.
4.5 โ€” A projection of high-performer growth
The modeled performance of two theoretical organizations starting at $5M in annual revenue today, growing at their respective cohortโ€™s growth rates, not adjusted for inflation.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Growth is each organizationโ€™s median five-year revenue CAGR across windows ending in 2019โ€“2025.
4.7 โ€” Gift size, by percentile
USD per donation, 2025.
10th
$10
25th
$14
median
$21
75th
$31
90th
$53
mean $32
4.8 โ€” Donor retention rate, by percentile
Share of the prior yearโ€™s donors who gave again this year, 2025.
10th
30%
25th
40%
median
58%
75th
69%
90th
76%
mean 55%
4.9 โ€” Recurring share of revenue, by percentile
Share of revenue from recurring (regular monthly) gifts.
10th
1%
25th
3%
median
8%
75th
31%
90th
63%
mean 21%

Mail, online, and uncategorized appeals are responsible for half of all revenue. But these channels are constantly changing.

Mail, online, and uncategorized appeals are responsible for half of all revenue. But these channels are constantly changing.

An organizationโ€™s top channel today is likely not what its top channel was ten years ago. Much is constantly changing. That makes judging โ€œtopโ€ channels fraught. Some mediums also lend themselves to a specific cause or appeal type. And it all depends on whether your goal is acquisition or repeat donations.

Mail is responsible for 26% of revenue, followed by online, at 13%

Please do not read this section as a call to divert more resources to mail. This number is extremely variable by cause type. It is also an indication that these channels are heavily used, and thus crowded. 

There is also the perennial challenge of measurement and attribution. Weโ€™ve done as much normalizing as we can on this data, but few organizations classify channels in the exact same way. Plus, most organizations (but not all) use last-touch attribution, meaning the final outreach channel that earns the donation wins 100% of the credit. This naturally skews results to more common and widely used channels, and channels used later in the donation cycle. 

5.1 โ€” Revenue by channel source, aka where money comes from
Each source as a share of total revenue.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
5.2 โ€” Most-used channels
Left: The share of organizations that raise any revenue through each channel. Right: Among those that do, the median share of their revenue each channel brings in.
Left: Share of organizations using the channel
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Right: Median share of revenue among those using it
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Showing each organizationโ€™s latest year, 2025, and acquisition channels only. Excludes revenue tagged to an โ€œotherโ€ channel.

Appeals and one-off gifts have declined as a share over time, while recurring giving, community and events, corporate and trusts, and bequests have risen. 

5.3 โ€” Percent of total revenue by gift category, 2000 vs. 2025
Share of categorized revenue.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

In-person channels are your best bet for acquisition

Pictured, we can also view the revenue that came in for seven channels, broken down by gift type. We can see a clear divide between in-person channels for acquiring new donors, and remote and digital channels, which are good for keeping in touch with people once theyโ€™ve donated. 

5.4 โ€” The type of gift each channel tends to produce
Each bar totals to 100% of that channelโ€™s revenue in 2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

Each cause area relies on very different sources of revenue

All rely on appeals, but in very different proportions. The Environment category was difficult to calculate because that sample size is small and contains quirks that make it difficult to categorize.

5.5 โ€” What one-off gifts are made of, by cause
One-off revenue by gift category, 2023 to 2025, weighted by dollars raised.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
One-off means every gift that is not a regular recurring gift.

All causes have seen dramatic changes in their funding models

No cause type is playing by the same game as they were a decade ago. We selected two relatively stable periods within our dataset to compare, which coincidentally line up with two global crises, each of a different nature. Pictured is the current top revenue-producing gift type for each cause area, and what percentage of the revenue it comprises, compared to the prior period. Notice how greatly they shift within those cause areas.

We see this as an argument for agility, and for managing enough programs and channels that you have a โ€˜portfolioโ€™ with many โ€œinvestmentsโ€ you can turn to in times of need.  

5.6 โ€” How each standout causeโ€™s mix has shifted
Each source as a share of that causeโ€™s revenue, 2008โ€“12 vs. 2021โ€“25, average.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

66% of bequests were surprises

Two-thirds of realised bequests came from donors who had given under $7,000 USD in their lifetime. That โ€œbelow $7,000โ€ value is important, because it means these are typically not major donors, and so organizations are not actively tracking them or expecting those gifts. 

Bequests have roughly doubled their share of fundraising revenue since 2000, from 5% to nearly 10%. Most of that shift happened between 2005 and 2015. The share has held between 8% and 10% every year since, so the growth is banked rather than continuing.

5.7 โ€” Share of revenue from bequests over time
Bequests (gifts in wills) as a share of all revenue raised, each year, 2000โ€“2025.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
Pooled across the sector: total bequest dollars divided by total dollars raised, so the largest organizations count for the most. The number of organizations reporting grows from 200 in 2000 to 301 in 2025.
5.8 โ€” Surprise bequests by region
Share of realized bequests left by donors whose total prior giving to that organization was under $7,000 USD.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

Retention is the goal, but there are many paths there 

One might expect the answer to retention to be simple: All organizations should strive to convert one-time donors to recurring giving. But we found a substantial number of organizations with high retention that happen to have low recurring giving rates. The correlation is weak, and not as predictive as we thought.

Generally, organizations with more recurring giving are better retainers. But organizations that increased their share of recurring giving did not subsequently enjoy higher retention. Organizations with more recurring revenue do retain better (a correlation of 0.4 across organizations, see Chart 5.9). But organizations that raise their recurring share do not then see retention rise: Within organizations, year on year, the relationship is close to zero (-0.04 across 6,095 organization-years).

What can we conclude from this? That retention is due to many other factors not measurable in our data set. But, we can hypothesize: Given that itโ€™s possible to retain a healthy number of donors with a one-off model, it likely has more to do with the relationship that person feels like they have with the organization, the degree to which it is intertwined in their life, and the frequency with which they recall and interact with it.

5.9 โ€” Retention, by percentage recurring revenue
Median donor retention by recurring share of revenue, across all organization years.
Loading chartโ€ฆ
5.10 โ€” Recurring giving as a percentage of total revenue, by size
Share of revenue by gift type and organization size.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

Data is hard. Even among this relatively advanced group of nonprofits using predictive analysis, revenue with no identifiable acquisition channel runs from 13% at environmental organizations to 67% at hospices. 

You might be tempted to assume that all those unmarked gifts were bequests, but they arenโ€™t. We dug deeper on one specific sampleโ€”see the chart pictured. They really are just anonymous dollars. 

A great deal of fundraising data is unmeasurable and the share varies more by cause than by anything you can control. You have to work with what you have. So go easy on yourself. And simply know the benchmarks within your cause that can help you make the greatest change.

6.1 โ€” How much revenue arrives outside any acquisition channel
Median share per organization, by cause.
Loading chartโ€ฆ

According to our analysis, organizations that benchmark where they stand on metrics that matter to them can manage said metrics and improve. Increasing your retention alone from typical to top quartile can be worth an additional 15% in revenue. Moving into the successful cohort could mean growing 2.5x faster over the next decade.

Thatโ€™s the path to winning the abundance dividend: Entering a period where revenue is predictable enough that it creates a sense of internal calm. It might not necessarily remove the stress, but it allows people to plan and focus all their talents and efforts, finally, fully, on the mission. 

The best place for recommendations specific to your cause, size, and region is our data studio. But below, we sum up the general lessons from this report.

Key takeaways

Know your model

Recurring, retention, or lifetime value. Benchmark against those metrics.

Run tests to improve your second-gift retention rate

And know that the answer is not necessarily to get people to sign up for recurring donations, although it could be.

Strive to send less

The lesson from the last 10 years is emphatic: Sending more is not worth it in the long run, because response rates drop and eventually it stops working.

Use data to predict

When you can model what segments are likely to give when, and how much, you can reduce all that unnecessary outreach.